Laurel Pointe After Toll Brothers: What Resale Prices Say About Lot, Premium, and Value in Lake Nona
July 23, 2026
July 23, 2026
Toll Brothers announced the final sales opportunity at Laurel Pointe in May 2025, with the last Collage Collection homes priced from $1.7 million. Roll forward to summer 2026 and the nine active resales inside the same gates carry an average list price of about $2.59 million. That gap is the story. It tells you what the builder was under-charging for, what the resale market has since repriced, and where a buyer's leverage actually lives inside a 124-home enclave.
If you have already scrolled the portals, you have seen the list prices. What the portals do not show is why two homes of similar square footage inside the same guard-gated community can trade nearly a million dollars apart. Almost all of it comes down to lot.
Toll Brothers' own builder page carries a single line worth reading twice: home price does not include any home site premium. In new construction, the base price buys you the plan. The lot is a separate line item, and in Laurel Pointe those lots were not created equal. The community was platted around water and preserve views, and Toll's final phase released a run of sites backing onto a water conservation area, per the builder's May 2025 announcement.
That premium was invisible on the base sticker. It shows up now on resale. When Homes by Marco tracks nine active listings averaging roughly $2.59 million, ranging from about 2,989 to 7,093 square feet, the spread inside that range is not primarily about plan or finish level. It is about which side of the pond the house sits on.
Toll delivered Laurel Pointe in two lines that operate almost as separate markets:
Collection | Typical plan footprint | Where it sits | Resale posture |
|---|---|---|---|
Collage | ~2,976 to ~4,236 sq ft (Bordeaux, Grenache, Marsanne, Corbeil, Dolcetto) | Standard lots, many with preserve or interior water frontage | The volume of current resale activity; where the $1.7M final-phase base originated |
Mosaic | ~4,413 to 5,801+ sq ft (Barbera, Varen) | Phases 2 and 3, 90-foot-wide homesites | Where third-party trade coverage puts pricing in the $1.8M to $3.5M range |
A buyer touring in 2026 who assumes the Marsanne and the Varen are simply "bigger and smaller versions of the same thing" will misread the market. They are on different lot cohorts, and they behave differently on resale.
The relevant reading is not the average. It is the shape of the ladder. The base final-phase Toll price sat at $1.7 million in May 2025. A Central Florida buyer's guide published in late June 2026 puts larger Laurel Pointe homes around 5,000 square feet at $2 million to $3 million-plus. Homes by Marco's active-listing average lands squarely inside that band.
Three things are happening at once:
For a buyer, the practical read is that the interior of the pricing range is where negotiation has room. The top is anchored by scarcity, the bottom by product parity with adjacent Lake Nona neighborhoods.
Two transaction-specific frictions are worth flagging before an offer.
The first is amenity scope. Laurel Pointe's on-site amenities are limited to a waterfront open park and a dog park. Everything else, from fitness and pools to trail networks, comes from the broader Lake Nona amenity plan, which residents access through the master community. That matters at resale because appraisers pulling comps from full-amenity gated communities may over-index on Laurel Pointe's HOA, which Homes by Marco pegs at $248 to $333 per month. It is a lean HOA for a luxury enclave, and it is lean by design.
The second is property tax posture on new construction. The average annual property tax across Laurel Pointe listings sits near $7,759 per Homes by Marco, but that figure blends homesteaded resales with recently-closed builder deliveries where the assessed value has not yet reset. A buyer purchasing a resale from a non-homesteaded seller should model a post-sale reassessment before locking their carrying cost. The Orange County Property Appraiser publishes the millage and Save Our Homes rules directly at ocpafl.org, and running a projected tax before you write the offer is not optional at this price point.
Buyers comparing luxury Lake Nona typically weigh Laurel Pointe against three near-peers. Each solves a different problem.
Lake Nona Golf & Country Club is the established custom-home benchmark. Reported entry sits from about $1.6 million for existing product, with custom builds ranging well above that, and the draw is the Tom Fazio course and club membership. You are buying prestige, tenure, and a golf lifestyle.
Isles of Lake Nona, immediately southeast, competes on gated privacy at a lower price band and a different product profile.
Eagle Creek, directly across Narcoossee Road, is a 24-hour guard-gated golf community with a broader price range and a resale market that has been active for years.
Laurel Pointe's specific position is newer construction, guard-gated, no golf, water or preserve frontage, and a much smaller total home count than any of its neighbors. Scarcity is the number one input into its resale premium. There will only ever be 124 of these houses.
Location is doing real work here. The Laurel Pointe entrance sits at Narcoossee Road and Luminary Boulevard, directly across from a newer phase of Laureate Park. Luminary Elementary and Luminary Middle are diagonally across the entrance. Lake Nona Middle is roughly half a mile, Lake Nona High about 1.5 miles. Lake Nona Plaza with its Publix anchor is half a mile east. Orlando International Airport is 11 miles. Eagle Creek Golf Club is a mile away for buyers who want course access without club-dues obligations.
The May 2026 opening of the 405,000-square-foot Lake Nona West retail center adds another anchor within a short drive. UCF Lake Nona Hospital, which earned LEED Gold certification as the first hospital in Florida to do so, sits inside the Medical City employment base that drives much of the buyer pool at this price point.
If you are underwriting an offer, three questions matter more than the sticker:
That is the frame the average list price does not give you.
Are new Toll Brothers homes still available in Laurel Pointe? Toll Brothers announced the final sales opportunity in May 2025 at pricing from $1.7 million. Availability is essentially exhausted, and the active market has moved to resale.
What is the HOA at Laurel Pointe? Homes by Marco reports HOA dues ranging from $248 to $333 per month across current listings, which is modest for a guard-gated luxury enclave and reflects the community's lean on-site amenity set.
Does Laurel Pointe have its own pool or clubhouse? On-site amenities are limited to a waterfront open park and a dog park. Broader fitness, pool, and trail access comes through the master Lake Nona amenity network.
Which schools serve Laurel Pointe? Luminary Elementary and Luminary Middle sit diagonally across the community entrance. Lake Nona Middle is about half a mile and Lake Nona High about 1.5 miles away.
How does Laurel Pointe compare to Lake Nona Golf & Country Club for a luxury buyer? Different problems. Golf & Country Club is the established custom and club-lifestyle address with existing product from roughly $1.6 million. Laurel Pointe is newer, smaller at 124 homes, gated without golf, and priced almost entirely on lot premium and scarcity.
If you are weighing a specific Laurel Pointe address against the broader Lake Nona luxury field, or thinking about listing a home you bought in an early phase, the pricing is in the lot before it is in the plan. Sanz Luxury Team works this enclave with the lot-level detail the portal comps miss. Get Your Luxury Home Valuation and we will price your home against the current 124-home reality, not last year's builder sheet.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Looking to sell your home, relocate, or invest in a new construction or custom-built home? The Sanz Luxury Team, powered by eXp Realty, offers a team of highly skilled professionals dedicated to providing exceptional service. With our intelligence, creative problem-solving skills, and proven track record, we're committed to elevating your real estate experience. Let us guide you to success.